In his New York Times column complaining about Huffington Post and the new economics of content competition, I think David Carr makes two understandable but fundamentally fallacious assumptions about news and media: that the value in journalism is in content and that making content must be work. Because that's the way it used to be.
In their op-ed the next day in the New York Times complaining about copyright losing its hardness, Scott Turow, Paul Aiken, and James Shapiro extend the error to entertainment, assuming that content is entertainment and content is what content makers make.
Not necessarily.
Pull back to view the true value of these things: information, knowledge, enlightenment, amusement, experience, engagement. Content can be and has been a vessel to deliver their worth. But it is not the only one. That is the lesson of the internet -- indeed, of Huffington Post itself. I have argued that the New York Times, the Washington Post, CNN, the BBC, and other media should have but never would have started the Huffington Post because they, like the gentlemen above, still see content as value in itself and further believe that content is their own franchise (granted by their control of the means of production and distribution). So the benefits of content cannot come from others -- bloggers, commenters, citizens, amateurs -- as new wine in new casks. They instead want to put their old wine in the new skins (witness The Daily).
That is why old media people are missing new opportunities. It's not about the content (stupid). It's about the value.
We can be informed now by many means: by our neighbors telling us what they know, enabled to do so by the net, at a marginal cost of zero, doing so not because it is work (and work must be paid) but because this is what neighbors do for each other. We can be entertained by many means: by clever people making songs and shows and telling stories because they love doing so and because they are compensated in attention rather than royalties (and that attention may well lead to money when they can finally detour around the gauntlet of old media's closed ways to find audiences on their own).
Why do people write on Huffington Post? Because they can. Because they give a shit. Because they like the attention and conversation. Because they couldn't before. Why do they sing their songs on YouTube? Same reasons.
Is there still a role for the journalist, the professional, the artist in this? Perhaps. I think so. That's why I am teaching journalism school. But I'm not necessarily teaching them to make content. That is now only one of many, many ways to meet the goals of adding value to information, time, and society. Some of my entrepreneurial journalism students are, for example, creating businesses that will use data to impart information; they will add value by gathering and analyzing it and making it possible for you to find the intersecting points that matter to you. Other of my students are creating platforms for you to get more value out of your own data. Others are creating platforms for people to connect around interests and make and find their own value. Others are finding new ways to sustain reporting and the making of content. They are all valid if they bring value.
If you concentrate on the value, not the form -- content -- then the possibilities explode.
Turow et al shut down the idea that opening up information can yield greater value that protecting it. Sharers are...
... abetted by a handful of law professors and other experts who have made careers of fashioning counterintuitive arguments holding that copyright impedes creativity and progress. Their theory is that if we severely weaken copyright protections, innovation will truly flourish. It's a seductive thought, but it ignores centuries of scientific and technological progress based on the principle that a creative person should have some assurance of being rewarded for his innovative work.
No, I'd say rather that there are more ways to open up value. If Wikipedia were copyrighted by a publisher, it never would have become Wikipedia because it would be owned, not shared. We now have a new means to collect value rather than merely to own content.
I remember at the DLD conference a few years ago when Wikipedia founder Jimmy Wales defended himself from a ninja-knife-wielding Jason Calacanis over paying people to contribute to online resources. Calacanis, like Carr, called it work. Wales instead likened it to a pickup game of basketball. Viewed from a distance, basketball certainly looks like work; they sweat enough. So why don't we demand that they be paid? Why aren't we lamenting the loss of a marketplace for their value? Because that's not where the value is. It's in the fun.
Granted, what's done with that fun -- how it is exploited -- is relevant. If I start charging admission to watch you play basketball -- it is great content, after all -- or if I put sponsors' banners on the court -- you did draw an audience -- you might want a cut. If you can get it -- if you can show that there aren't a million competitors for court time in an open marketplace -- great! But what if the gate or the ads merely support my ability to provide free court time to you or free uniforms to your town-team kids? The economics are not necessarily sweat = work = product = pay. Neither is it any longer true that owning the expensive means of production and distribution assures a return on that investment. There are other expressions of value.
The truth is that Huffington Post recognizes the value of professionalism. I've lately recalled Arianna Huffington talking with Guardian editor-in-chief Alan Rusbridger in London a few years ago when he -- with native irony, in front of his reporters -- asked why the hell she was hiring reporters, who are a pain in the ass to manage and expensive to boot. Because their stories get more traffic, she said. They add value. That's why she has editors and curators. They add value. That's why she has technologists who make the Huffington Post such a social experience. They enable value.
That's what I'm teaching my entrepreneurial students: add value. And be efficient: take advantage of the free exchange that is already happening -- the free and open platforms and the information that now easily passes on them. Then put your precious resources where you most add value. Do that before you even think of extracting value. There are the new economics of what we used to think of as content.
Christian Louboutin Leopard Print Slingback Sandal Dllian Flower Pumps Silver-grayChristian Louboutin High heels are famously one of the ways which women suffer for fashion, although luxury christian louboutin are often assumed to be more comfortable. Louboutin discussed comfort, but it seems that isnt his main concern.It is important because a woman doesnt look good if shes not comfortable. But I wouldnt take it as a compliment if someone looked at one of my shoes and said, that looks like a comfortable shoes. Its not like shes going to suffer for it. Throughout the interview he stressed that he never wanted to be part of the fashion world. He commented, I never was interested in being part of the fashion world – I just wanted to design shoes. Christian Louboutin Libelle Sandals are adored by celebrites like Madonna, Carla Bruni and Lady Gaga, but he revealed that the woman hed really like as a customer is The Queen of England.Footwear genius Christian Louboutin gave an interview to The Guardian this weekend where he spoke candidly about the comfort of heels, who hed like to dress and those Barbie rumours. Get a pair of Christian Louboutin Leather Tall Boots Brown, of course comes at a price. However, if you buy them via the Internet, you can find a pair of Christian Louboutin Light Green Reticular discount at a fraction of the price you would pay for them originally. http://www.louboutinshoes4lady.com/
Surface Encounters proudly guarantees customer satisfaction and price tag installing granite assurance. “I’m consistently skeptical going with new businesses, but your workers has created me a believer!” - Steve, Indianapolis
Surface Encounters is mostly a fast-growing
surface encounters company and, yet still they've kept tempo with each of the recent consumer referrals. “This business is amongst the most cost-effective, reliable and friendly organizations during the complete state. I would encourage them to virtually anyone.” - Mike R., South Bend
Lots of operate goes into establishing fabulous countertops from nature. The method incorporates laser measurement creative vein matching, precision diamond and water-jet cutting, edging and experienced set up. One can not simply just contact in their order to get a customized countertop and also have it within just a day or two. Superior requires time.
Surface Encounters encourages people today to go to a showroom to discover more about natural stone countertops. Moreover the collection and fabrication process, one more crucial piece of purchaser treatment is making sure one particular is aware easy methods to care for their granite countertop to keep it wanting new for decades to come.
Granite is definitely a beautiful organic stone product which is a well-liked content employed for countertops and floor tiles in kitchens and bathrooms. Granite has surpassed marble in reputation considering is it even more sturdy and less complicated to care for. Granite is unmatched by synthetic merchandise for its strength and sturdiness, tolerance to temperature changes and resistance to stains and scratches.
Granite is mostly a naturally formed stone that is definitely quarried from deep with the earth, harvested, lower, polished, sealed and set up in houses to add splendor, elegance and fashion. As a result of it is a organic product or service, no two slabs are particularly alike. Granite is available in quite a few colours in the several minerals which can be uncovered inside the rock. Due to the fact it arrives from all over the world, totally different regions and environmental issues allow it to be distinctive.
Granite is mainly developed up of quartz crystal, but it also incorporates different quantities of other metals like feldspar, mica, copper and iron. Some granite may perhaps contain bits of gold or silver. The quantity of each metal depends on the region it comes from. All granite is shaped into a tricky stone by warmth and pressure. Rain adds other minerals since it is forming. It can be to choose from throughout the planet, in every last nation, and each and every region will generate a
surface encounters exceptional number of granite.
Surface Encounters state-of-the-art machinery makes sure the highest excellent completed item as they design and style and establish a number of the finest kitchens and bathrooms. Granite Countertops greatly enhance the warmth and elegance of homes while rising their value and bettering lifestyles.
Surface Encounters is also concerned with employee morale; satisfied personnel are further probably to lead to the good results of a organization. Furthermore to getting a triumphant organisation and one that is certainly wonderful to deliver the results for, Surface Encounters does their part to preserve our planet.
Surface Encounters does what on earth is suitable for his or her users, employees as well as the setting. Surface Encounters uses innovative h2o recycling capabilities to recycle up to 43,000 gallons of water on a daily basis. Additionally, 100 percent for the scrap produced in constructing elegant kitchens and beautiful baths is re-used as aggregate in street developing, surface preparations and concrete.
The Columbus, Ohio Grand Opening of Surface Encounters options an art gallery showroom of Granite, Marble, Quartz and Engineered Stone counter tops. Store Supervisor, Scott Donnelly unlocked the doorways from the showroom at 4717 Roberts Road, just west of your I-270 Beltway. The Surface Encounters manufacturing practice makes use of precision, automated technological innovation throughout the fabrication on the customer's personalized counter top rated, these kinds of as: a laser measuring alignment that plans the diamond-tipped sculpturing blades. Surface Encounters' method contains computer-driven software package that perpetuates the stone's all natural veins. All Surface Encounter retail store has no less than a person registered, interior designer to assist you in establishing the finished venture you will be looking for. The craftsmanship continues with the
House owners are deciding to remodel instead than sell their residences in today’s market place
Granite countertops are becoming a top rated alternative between Wixom buyers for kitchen remodeling jobs. Kitchen remodeling is usually the 1st project tackled with households shelling out three,000 hours or more each year in their kitchen. Granite countertops offer an natural environment that enhances the top notch time invested with spouse and children and friends. Granite countertops last a lifetime and improve the high quality of real estate.
Surface Encounters Wixom retailer manager, Sal Dellacasa, says there are numerous explanations consumers are choosing granite for his or her countertop requires. “Granite countertops add splendor and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is obtainable inside a number of vibrant colors and abundant textures and its strength and sturdiness is unmatched by any other organic stone or synthetic countertop substance.”
Surface Encounters’ clientele benefit from pro services as well as a pleasant, effective employees to guidebook them through the kitchen remodeling course of action. Several of Surface Encounters new prospects are referred to them by past buyers.
"This company is probably the most budget friendly, dependable, and friendly suppliers in the complete state. I'd recommend them to virtually anyone." Mike R. Clinton Twp., MI
"The business has continually been there to assist me in whichever way probable. Thank you a lot!" David V. Lapeer, MI
Surface Encounters Macomb will be the property of half-off granite for kitchen and bathroom countertops. Granite countertops by Surface Encounters have rather quickly come to be the high alternative for Macomb residents that are remodeling their kitchens. Kitchen remodeling takes priority with families paying 3,000 hours or more per year within their kitchen. Granite countertops supply an surroundings that enhances the excellent time invested with loved ones and friends and advance the superior of homes.
Surface Encounters Macomb store supervisor, Sal Dellacasa, says there are numerous explanations consumers are picking out granite for his or her countertop desires. “Granite countertops add elegance and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is offered within a number of vibrant hues and loaded textures and its strength and durability is unmatched by any other
surface encounters all natural stone or synthetic countertop materials.”
Surface Encounters’ clients get pleasure from skilled service in addition to a friendly, very helpful workers to guidebook them through the kitchen remodeling approach. A great number of of Surface Encounters new users are referred to them by prior shoppers.
JJ Evans Says:
February 17th, 2011 at 7:58 pm
Wiz Khalifa:
Homicide = Beat is trash and song is trash.
Taylor Gang = Beat is FIRE. Put Ross on it and I’ll fuck with the actual song. I really can ‘t fuck wit Wiz on this. Sorry
b Says:
February 17th, 2011 at 8:09 pm
Money money money.magic Johnson looking healthy than a mufuka, meanwhile that aids shit wiped out my family early.people still dying from it.pardon me